Loading
Latest News |
(See all)

Press Releases

In Case You Missed It: US Government: “We Can Ban Books”

03/26/2009

US Government: “We Can Ban Books”

Dep. Solicitor General Argues Jailing Book Publishers Is Constitutional

During Tuesday’s oral arguments in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, the government told the Supreme Court that it has the constitutional authority to send a commercial book publisher to prison for publishing a book that contains the words “Vote for _____” within two months of an election.

Below are selected editorials and op-eds from around the country supporting Citizens United’s position against the Federal Election Commission on this critical First Amendment issue.

To arrange for an interview with David Bossie, President of Citizens United, please contact 202.547.5420.

USA TODAY OP-ED: Top court reviews 'Hillary, the movie' 3/26/09 It isn't often that a government lawyer stands before the Supreme Court and acknowledges that yes, it would be constitutional to ban a book. But that is what happened on Tuesday, as Deputy Solicitor General Malcolm Stewart defended a campaign-reform law that treated an anti-Hillary Clinton movie in 2008 as an election ad — an advertisement that could be restricted, even banned, because a corporation paid for it.

WSJ EDITORIAL: Free Speech: The Movie 3/26/09

According to Deputy Solicitor General Malcolm Stewart, who argued the case, the government could theoretically regulate other forms of pre-election corporate speech as well, including books and the Internet. "That's pretty incredible," said Justice Samuel Alito. "You think that if a book was published, a campaign biography that was the functional equivalent of express advocacy, that could be banned?" Yes, Mr. Stewart said, if a corporation or union were paying for it. It would be possible to "prohibit the publication of the book using the corporate treasury funds."

WASH TIMES EDITORIAL: Campaign finance law scrutinized 3/26/09

Deputy Solicitor General Malcolm Stewart's argument before the court on behalf of the Federal Election Commission that the government could use the law to stop the distribution of election-related books, electronic media to an Amazon Kindle reader, and even ads for action figures representing candidates for federal office if they are paid for by corporate funding, is incredibly disconcerting.

RICHMOND TIMES EDITORIAL: The U.S. v. Books 3/26/09

The debate over the First Amendment implications of campaign-finance law reached its logical terminus in oral arguments before the Supreme Court Tuesday when lawyers for the federal government said it should be able to ban books. . . . Deputy Solicitor General Malcom Stewart said it does not matter how long a campaign commercial is, and it does not matter if the film is a quasi-documentary. A movie is no different from a campaign ad if it appeals to voters for the election or defeat of a political candidate.

  
    
Subscribe RSS

Latest Updates

Breitbart: LEFTISTS STILL SHOUTING ‘FIRE!’ OVER CITIZENS UNITED RULING

We all know that you can’t shout “fire” in a...

The Washington Post: Changing pay-to-play politics

As the April 6 editorial “Political speech or corruption?” argued,...

Cagle: Democrats with Their Heads in the Clouds

As Congress jetted off to yet another recess, many liberals...

Breitbart: THE OLD (DEMS) AND THE RESTLESS

When comparing the potential Republican and Democrat fields for president...

CU In The News

Greenville News: Scott will attend conservative gathering next month

The list of well-known politicians planning to speak at a...

Greenville News: Rubio to attend candidate forum in Greenville next month

At least two declared Republican presidential candidates are scheduled to...

National Review: Hillary Says We Should Rewrite the First Amendment, If That’s What It Takes to Reverse Citizens United

Hillary Clinton endorsed a constitutional amendment today to reverse the...

The Wall Street Journal: Hillary: The Censor Citizens United was about the right to criticize her.

“I think it’s fair to say that . . ....

© 2014 - Citizens United - 202-547-5420
1006 Pennsylvania Ave SE - Washington, DC 20003
Privacy Policy